NYC Taxi Pick Poor Pick For Wheelchair Users

KarsanAn opportunity missed is an opportunity lost. That’s exactly what happened in NYC when Bloomberg lead powers picked the wrong taxi.

One never knows what motivates “the powers” to exercise their authority in any given direction on any given day and for what purpose they exercise.

It certainly looks like they worked over a large number of NYC wheelchair users when Mayor Bloomberg & Company failed to pick the Karsan wheelchair accessible taxi (shown above) that could save taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars, as well as serve wheelchair users and the ever growing aging population.

“If this decision holds, it will be a black eye on the legacy of Mayor Bloomberg’s administration as it is financially inexcusable and perpetuates discrimination against people with disabilities for the next ten years,” stated James Weisman, United Spinal Association senior vice president and general counsel.

Read the rest.

It appears that they overlooked a wheelchair and scooter friendly taxi made by a Turkish company, Karsan that could be made in Brooklyn employing 800 workers and chose, instead, an inaccessible Nissan cab.

This is lost opportunity, or worse, it’s a slap in the face and kick in the ass to New York City’s wheelchair using population who have now been presented with yet another barrier to their mobility.

The added barrier is a discrete one that the walking public may not even understand. A present NYC sedan style taxi, even though not wheelchair accessible, allows some extent of unassisted or assisted transfer from a wheelchair to the cab seat for those wheelchair users who can manage it.

A mini-van such as the one chosen by NYC presents a much greater barrier. Seats are higher and set back in the vehicle. For the vast majority of wheelchair users who can do a transfer this would mean transferring to the floor of the vehicle and then attempting an uphill transfer from the vehicle floor to the seat. Forget it! Very few wheelchair users can manage or want to attempt that dangerous trick with or without assistance.

So, things have now worsened for the taxi using wheelchair riding citizens of New York City. Those that had the dexterity, ambition, and fortitude to attempt manual transfers into an NYC taxi will probably not be able or want to tackle this newly purchased obstacle.

It’s disappointing of course coming from a city and administration that considers itself forward thinking and progressive. What’s worse, other cities often follow the lead of bigger ones, so this may be the beginnings of a national roll-back on accessible transportation. That would be quite bogus indeed.

Filed Under: FeaturedPraise and Scorn

RSSComments (3)

Leave a Reply | Trackback URL

  1. WheelzMcGee says:

    I understand it may be more difficult for some wheelchair users to transfer to one of the seats in the taxi. However, if the person who uses the wheelchair can not transfer they also have the option of remaining in the wheelchair and riding that way don’t they?

    Also, for the person who still wants to use the standard “sedan style” taxi and transfer from the chair to the seat still can. There doesn’t seem to be a shortage of those in NYC.

    The bottom line, instead of perceiving this as another obstacle we should view this as another option for people that use wheelchairs. NYC should be applauded for their continued effort to provide those options. People who use wheelchairs that live in other areas of the country do not have nearly as many transportation options.

  2. Ziggi says:

    Not quite Wheelz. The minivan that was selected Is Not Wheelchair Accessible. If the wheelchair using taxi flagger wishes to stay in their wheelchair while cabbing it, well, it’s just not possible. So the alternatives for the patron are to keep waving down taxis until they hit on an accessible one (good luck), do a transfer if possible, or start humping your wheelchair down the avenue (a very common solution in NYC).

  3. Brittany Correa says:

    Hi. My name is Brittany Correa. I am a wheelchair bound New Yorker, and I was disenheartened by the recent news that the New York City has recently commisioned the purchase of taxicabs that do not implement wheelchair accesibility as part of their standard model. Because it is unlikely that taxi drivers are going to pay to convert their own vehicles, I have started a petition to mandate and subsidize the implementation of wheelchair accessible taxicabs throughout the state.

    here is my petition.

    http://www.change.org/petitions/ask-new-york-state-to-mandate-and-subsidize-wheelchair-accessible-taxicabs

    Thank you for your time.